Some quotes from Create A World Clinic

I’m plugging along this morning, getting good stuff.

Thought I’d share a couple snippets. NOTE: These are raw first draft, un-spellchecked or edited, and may contain typos or worse. THESE ARE NOT FINAL DRAFT.

First, the Definitions

Worldbuilding is the creation of a setting or settings that will contain a story, plus the essential elements needed to tell the story well.


A fictional world is the setting or settings that contain a single story, and the essential elements the writer uses to tell it.


The SANE process of worldbuilding is to do as only the work you absolutely MUST have, and to do it only when you need it.

…and finally…

For a writer…
…The purpose of worldbuilding is to quickly create the section of a living, breathing universe you need to add depth to the part of the story you’re writing right now.

Then, the Problem

I keep saying every writer, no matter the genre or the story type (from short story to mega-novel monster series) needs to worldbuild, and writers keep not believing me.

But what I say when I say worldbuilding, and what they envision, are two totally different animals. So, another two snippets, each of these a bit longer.

What I Believed for Years

For years, I was utterly convinced that massive, comprehensive, complete, all-done-in-advance-of-writing Tolkien-style worldbuilding was the only way I’d managed to get published in the first place, and that it was the step in the process that allowed me to write books. That I had to have it.

I told people this, too. There I was, with my thumb in my mouth and my security blanket over my head, saying, “My security blanket is why I sold the Arhel series and the Secret Texts series and the World Gates series, and all the stand-alones in between.”

It wasn’t the stories. Couldn’t have been that. My editors bought my work because of the indigestible backstory that damn near killed every one of the ones I sent it to.

Of course they did. 🙄

You can mistake the thing that’s killing your writing for the thing that’s making it work.

And make no mistake: My worldbuilding was killing my writing. I’m a really fast worldbuilder, but even at high speed and working long hours, I’d spend months building everything I thought I needed before I put together a synopsis to send to my agent—who would then shoot me down, and rather than just fix the story, I’d fix the world first, and then fix the story.


How I Ferreted Out the Truth

I knew my books were selling, so I could prove that I was writing salable fiction. That was my point of known truth.

I believed my work sold because of all the worldbuilding I did before I started writing.

But one day, I tripped over the contradiction, and it was this: I absolutely never used all or even most of the worldbuilding I did, and much more than half of my work from any pre-novel worldbuilding orgy ended up unusable because of the better ideas I had while I was writing. Sometimes, all of that pre-novel worldbuilding went down the tubes. Once. Even twice.

Therefore, my Tolkien-style completist worldbuilding was not what sold my books.

So what I’m teaching is not Tolkien-style completist worldbuilding. I’m teaching the sort of worldbuilding that actually DID help me sell my novels, and that routinely has readers saying, “I finished this series with the impression that Matrin was real and that, given the chance, I could find my way in it: this is what I call impressive worldbuilding,” and from another reader, “I discovered that she was able to flesh out her world while advancing her story and introducing her characters. Well done,” and “But Lisle’s true strength lies in her world-building. Talyn’s despair at seeing her people’s culture being thrown up in flames is our own, because by then, we are able to appreciate its beauty and rarity.”

I’m a solid writer overall. I plot well, I write cleanly and coherently, I do good conflict and I understand story, and know how to tell one.

I have two great strengths, though. One is that I can make my worlds live in readers’ minds. The other is that I can dissect processes, and explain and demonstrate how I do them.

In Create A World Clinic, I’m doing the two things I’m best at simultaneously. I suspect this was part of why I kept putting this book off. I knew all along that once it was finished, it was the one on which all the others would be judged.

So I have a lot at stake writing this one.

And with that… onward.

image_pdfDownload as PDFimage_printPrint Page







12 responses to “Some quotes from Create A World Clinic”

  1. Jennifer Avatar

    Hi, Holly — I stumbled upon your blog by accident and am hooked. Your gems of wisdom are top notch, and your generosity in sharing them amazing.

    I love what you say about world-building, especially the impressionist (if I understood it correctly) approach.

    Thanks so much for this wonderful website. I fully intend to check out some of your books.

    1. Holly Avatar

      Hi, Jennifer.

      Welcome to the site. 😀

  2. Yog-Sothoth Avatar


    Holly, it seems to me that this book might be of interest to those running role-playing games (like Dungeons & Dragons). Once you’ve got it written and launched that’s a potential market you might want to explore.

    1. Holly Avatar

      It might. Having DM’d, I know that my method would give DMs and GMs some new approaches to torturing their players.

      But because the book is written directly to the needs of novelists, and because the way I work is SO far away from tradition, I’m not sure they’d see the value before they flamed me for not following the Tolkien approach.

      1. KenB Avatar

        “…would give DMs and GMs some new approaches to torturing their players.”

        Too Funny! LOL!

        1. Holly Avatar

          Well, hell…that’s about three quarters of the fun of BEING a DM. Giving players all the tools they need to do something spectacular OR blow things up, and then watching them refuse to consider that careless actions have consequences until the consequences fall on their heads is…well…evilly grand.

  3. Jen of Hens Avatar
    Jen of Hens

    Holly – I needed to hear this today. I am getting very few, begrudging words lately because I’m clinging tightly to Tolkein’s hand. I may also have a security blanket over my head and several lucky amulets jingling on my charm bracelet and if I step on a crack….I’ll have to dump this book and write something else, ’cause I suck. Insert eyeroll here.

    Time to get over myself and write already!

    More words today – but first finish housecleaning and kissing Mr. Tolkein goodbye. He may want tea and scones before he leaves…

    1. Holly Avatar

      Tolkien bludgeoned me with a spiky dwarven mallet +5 for years before I finally cut him loose.

      I did in in Talyn—the final version that sold.

    2. Jen of Hens Avatar
      Jen of Hens

      472 words – totally off topic but for pay. Meh – whatever.

      Holly – I will now frisk Tolkein for dwarven malletry should he darken my larder again!

  4. Bethany Avatar

    Holly, I was wondering. Will this Build a World Clinic be in or out of sync with your previously published Clinics? I own all of them, and they all seem to feel that world building is pretty important. So, I’m just curious if this Tolkien-esque building style is what you are talking about in those books, or if you had already come to the conclusion that it wasn’t helping at the time of your writing?

    Good golly, I hope some of that makes sense.

    1. Holly Avatar

      Worldbuilding is the most critical task the writer undertakes.

      It just isn’t worldbuilding the way Tolkien did it. 😀

      The clinics are in synch.

  5. Rebecca Anne Avatar
    Rebecca Anne

    Holly may I say even if it’s a rough draft I can’t wait to read the finished article and judging by what I have read you don’t need to worry because it won’t let you down. The advice is still extremely high quality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x