Experts, Professionals, and College

“Do I have to have a college education to make it as a writer?” “I haven’t finished high school. Can I still write?” “I’ve always wanted to be a writer, and I’ve done a lot of writing, but I couldn’t afford to go to college when I was younger . . .”This question arrives in my e-mail box about once a week, worded in any of a dozen different ways. Some of the questioners tiptoe around it, embarrassed to ask, pretty sure they know what the answer is going to be, but hoping that it won’t. Sometimes I can feel the frustration and the pain, the barriers erected by poverty or lack of a diploma or lack of time. Some of the questioners are as young as thirteen, some have been as old a seventy.

All of them are pretty sure that formal education is the road to writing; that a degree will confer legitimacy to their words and their lives; that if they could just get more schooling, publishers’ doors would open.

They’ve been brainwashed by experts, by a system designed to create people who fit neatly into categories like ‘accountant’ and ‘nurse’ and ‘manager’. They’ve been trained to believe that the best education is an education that comes from sitting passively in a desk in an overcrowded room, being talked at by an expert.

Obviously, experts have gone to a great deal of trouble to make sure their potential customers (and perhaps you) believed this. They’ve tried to get employers to make grades the basis for hiring — a move most employers have so far been bright enough to refuse. They have managed to close many fields to anyone who hasn’t sat in the box like a good little drone for sixteen years or more.

You now have to have a degree to be an architect, a doctor, a teacher, or an engineer. Experts are trying to make sure you have to have a degree to become an RN. They’d also prefer that you had to have a degree in order to be a social worker, respiratory therapist, an interior decorator . . . and sooner or later, when they make degrees mandatory to those fields, I imagine they’ll get to work on truckers and plumbers and bakers and hairdressers. College-educated experts are trying to close every field, because college education is big, pricey business, and the more people that have to go through it, the more money the experts make.

And if you think I’m full of shit here, and that people really do need college educations before going out and doing great things, consider this — the gothic cathedrals, the pyramids, and the Roman roads and aqueducts were designed and built by men who did not have college educations. Michaelangelo did not have a college degree, nor did Leonardo da Vinci. Thomas Edison didn’t. Neither did Mark Twain (though he was granted honorary degrees in later life.) All of these people were professionals. None of them were experts.

Get your education from professionals, and always avoid experts.

An expert is somebody with a degree. The degree doesn’t mean he knows how to do what he’s an expert at — he might have absolutely no practical experience. But he has the degree, which confers on him the right to impress other people with his accomplishment (which was the getting of the degree), and to get paid for his expert opinions. An expert gets paid by third parties — his work is never placed in the open market where it will either sink or swim on its own merit. Experts earn more money and more security by conforming — if they conform for a long enough time without annoying anyone or doing anything unexpected, they can earn higher positions or, in college systems, tenure. Therefore, in an expert system, the talented, the challenging and the brash are weeded out, and the inoffensive mediocre remain. Many college professors are experts.

A professional is someone who makes a living working in the field in question. A professional architect designs and builds houses for clients. A professional hairdresser cuts and styles hair for clients. A professional writer writes stories, articles, or books for readers. All of these people get paid by the people who are direct consumers of their work. If they do bad work, they don’t get paid. The open market will weed out the bad professionals, so the ones who have been around for a while and who are still working are probably worth learning from.

What I learned from two years of nursing school at a community college was primarily political — “Get involved in your local chapter of the North Carolina Nursing Association, fight to keep the ANA from making a bachelor’s degree the entry level for an RN, don’t stand up when doctors come into the nurses’ station or give them your seat.” I learned some basics on patient care, too — but I didn’t really learn to be a nurse until I was out in the field working with other nurses. They were the ones who said, “Look, you see somebody who comes in looking like that, don’t wait for the doctor to get here before you stick O2 on him and order a twelve-lead. Just do it. And break out the D5W and start a microdrip IV right away, too. And for godsake, make sure the crash cart is ready and the paddles are warmed up.”

In writing, too, I learned the things I needed to know about the profession from a brief apprenticeship with Mercedes Lackey and another with Stephen Leigh. From Stephen, I learned the nuts and bolts of writing: 1. Avoid passive voice, 2. Use active verbs, 3. Eliminate most adjectives and adverbs, 4. Use concrete detail, 5. Tell a story worth telling, 6. Know your characters. From Misty, I learned how to be a professional — and that I learned from watching her. She came home from a full day of work and went straight into her office and wrote her ten pages . . . every day, no matter what kind of a day she’d had. Only when she’d done that did she come out and hang out. She was invariably polite and friendly to her agent, her editors, her publishers, and her fans. She worked on ideas for one project while writing another. She didn’t have a shit fit about having to do rewrites — she just did them. She hit her deadlines. She wrote stories she wanted to write.

There. I’ve just given you a complete apprenticeship in writing. You have everything you need to know to become a professional writer, and it took you a couple of minutes of your time and didn’t cost you a penny. The rest of being a professional writer is writing — sitting down and putting words on a page, one after another after another.

If you want to pay $40,000 or $60,000 or whatever for a college education, you can do that, and perhaps you’ll even have one or two professors in your program who are actually working as writers. They aren’t doing it full time, of course, because if they were, they wouldn’t be supplementing their income by teaching, so you won’t be able to model a full-time writer by watching them. You’ll have to spend a lot of time doing things that have no relationship to what you want to do with your life. And you need to remember that most people who go to college to become writers don’t. They find their focus shifted to education, or business, and they give up on their dream. College educations are designed by conformists to create conformists. Even those colleges which point to their radical stance and avante garde teaching are creating students who conform to their mold — their sort of radicals, their sort of avante garde. Students in college have to earn the approval of their teachers in order to get their grades and graduate. And you don’t learn anything new if your main goal in life is seeking the approval of experts.

If you’re looking at writing as a career, you’re looking at a future of tremendous freedom. You can do what you want to do with your life, and publishers and editors don’t ask if you have a degree, and don’t care if you have a degree. They only care that you can put good words on a page, and that you can tell a story. They’ll pay you well if you can do those two things — and you can learn to do them without a college education, without a high school education, without having spent a day in your life locked behind the walls of a classroom.

You’ll learn to write if you teach yourself. Put yourself in situations where you can learn new things from the people who actually do them. Hang out with policemen and painters and long-distance runners and carpenters. Get them to show you the tricks of their trade. Learn how to build a stained glass window, how to paddle a canoe, how to swim, how to bait your own hook and tie your own flies and how to identify the flowers and shrubs and trees native to your region. Grow a garden. Paint your own house and fix your own leaky faucet. Go camping with a couple of outdoorsy friends. Read lots and lots and lots of good books. Read fiction, read non-fiction. Especially read lots of books about complicated subjects written for the intelligent layman.

Never, never pick up a textbook — textbooks are worthless. They’re politically correct pablum designed to spoonfeed tiny bits of information to people who aren’t interested in the subject matter without offending those people’s parents. Anything designed with being inoffensive as its primary goal isn’t going to be worth your time — life itself is pretty offensive, ending as it does with death.

And while you’re doing all this reading and self-educating, keep writing. Have the guts to believe in yourself, have the guts to ignore the experts who want your money, have the guts to take a chance on making your dream a reality. You can do it.

Am I sure?

Yes, I am.

You see, I’m a full-time professional writer, and I don’t have a college education either.


Comments

Do Writers Need College To Write? — 9 Comments

  1. I’m taking most of your classes (I may be missing a couple), and I’m so glad I read this. I listened to some random YouTube lectures tonight, and ended up thinking maybe I should go back to school. I did that for a few semesters the last two years, but it drained my savings. Ironically, the most expensive was a two-week writing workshop, because I had to leave my work assignment for three weeks… Anyway, I’m glad I read this. I don’t need a diploma*, like the Wizard handed the Scarecrow. I just need to keep writing and listening to people like you. 🙂

    *I can’t remember what the Wizard called it – a testimonial, maybe?

  2. I am 18. I am graduating this Friday. I am the second child of six.The oldest girl, the mother hen so to say. I am the first girl on my father’s side in forty-seven years. My brother is a drop out, so is my younger sister. My parents expect so much of me considering there is only a hand full of relatives on both sides who actually got an education and wasn’t pregnant by the time they were fifteen. I want to make my mama proud because she’s worked hard to make life easy for me and my siblings. I don’t have money for college. I barely have money for a good meal at times, but me and my family have survived these troubled years and we’ve fought through. They expect me to become this “family legend” and when I told them back my freshman year I decided on my career path, my mama never looked prouder. I wanted to be a lawyer. All through high school I done research on law schools, took notes on what it would take for some small town, poor girl like me to make it big in a profession as that. I finished school back in January and as I was finishing up my paper work, my guidance counselor basically told me my test and academic scores weren’t good enough to become a lawyer. He said no school would even touch me with how low my ACT score was. It was a seventeen. I’m not stupid at all, I’m honestly very intelligent, they just expect so much for us these days. I’ve always been doubted by my peers and even some adults as well. I never, even as a child with the dificulties I faced, gave up. I like to prove people wrong, the ones who belittle me. Around the time I was supposed to apply to school, I hesitated. Not because of what my counselor said, but because I actually started thinking about it. I don’t want to become a lawyer who drones over their work. Who eventually become a zombie. I have an open personality. I’m full of energy and my friends consider me outgoing. I love the person I am, but I feel like if I become a lawyer I wouldn’t be able to express myself and show other people who I am. Even when I was little, during stressful times, I wrote. I wrote songs and poems and stories. I still to this day do that. Hell, I write down everything. English has always been my favorite and best subject and now that it’s almost time for me to be somebody, someone better, I’ve decided I want to write. I want to tell my beautiful and tragic stories. I want to bring hope and sorrow into my reader as my favorite books and authors have done to me. My parents don’t know about my career change and I’m not sure how they’ll handle it, but it makes me happy. I was just worried about what college I should look for to go to, and what kind of major and minor I need. Thanks to this article, I feel relieved because I don’t have the money for college, I have nothing saved up. I just love day by day. So thank for this, it’s gave me hope and right now I feel like I’m unstoppable.

  3. thx for advice I needed to see do you need to graduate from a school to be a writer so i can tell them this at my show n tell 😀

  4. So glad I came across this article. Just plain speak – so refreshing – off to explore your website – thanks Holly .

  5. Holly,

    Thank you for your honest opinion. Well said! I’m actually, kinda glad I wasn’t able to finish college… I’m looking forward to reading more of your work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *